Political
History of Europe
1.
Magna Carta
2. The New Age
3. The French Revolution
and Democracy
4. The Major Reasons Preparing
the Tsar’s Russia to Bolshevik Revolution and Democracy
5. The Mussolini government
in Italy and the union of workers of Marx
Magna Carta
During the Middle Ages, when the kings
were the only authority, it was impossible for the division
of forces to take place. Monarchs of the Middle Ages base
their rule on sword and conquer which enable the founder of
the country to rule for this reason. The people who are conquering
lands of founding country in the name of God were treated
as selected people. As a result of this; it would be a very
hard decision for a king with unlimited power, to be under
the mondate of a more powerful king.
In such Aa period, when
I.Richard left his throne to his brother John it was a very
big issue concerning today’s democracies, that King
John accepted to limit his own power with Magna Carta.
The treaty, which was
signed between the king and Barons in 1215, has the characteristic
of being the firstconstition. King John, who is using all
the feudal powers of his throne to reconquer Normandy and
Poitu, facer an increasing opposition especially in North
england. Bounnes and La Roche-aux-moins which were added to
the new economical responsabilities were very hard thatthe
barons were on the way of a rebellion. Consequantly, Barons
rebelled, but couldn’t defeated the profossional soldiers
and the castles around england. In 17 May 1215 Barons and
citizens of London agree and the Barons conquerd London. King
John left closed in Windsor. This situation is the creator
of Magna Carta, and it enabled the bargain between the King
and the Barons in June in Runnymede.
Magna Carta consist of
63 points. Some of these points lost importance as time passed,
whereas some became more important. Some exemples of the points
are:
1- Church will be opuot
of King’s intervention
2- Marchants will not pay arbitrary taxes
3- Nobody will be punished unless trailed by equals before
the laws
4- The king will be trialed and punished by the Barons if
he doesn’t obey the treaty.
These points are importent
building blocks of the modern state formations states have
reached the secular ideology through these first steps. It’s
obvious that, the the statement of abolishment of unbound
authority, which is the essence of modern states, is a big
step toward reaching today’s idea of democrarcy. The
third part (above) is one of the important steps that enabled
yhe judicary to work in a just way. It also shows us the conditions
of the fourth point providing a prototype for the control
of legislative and executive powers.
Some of points of Magna
carta became the fundamental principles of modern states.
This treaty is important for various countries history of
constitutional law as well as England. This treaty has become
the fundemental source of constitutional rule system.
Selman Saglam
Bibliography:
Demokrasi nedir? Tarihi ve Felsefesi - Prof. Dr. Mehmet Ali
AYNÎ
Yanar Yayýnlarý 1989 / Ýstanbul
Yeni Türk Ansiklopedisi - Ötüken Neþriyat
- 1985 / Ýstanbul
Demokrasi - Toktamýþ ATEÞ - Ümit Yayýncýlýk
1994 / Ankara
The New Age
The New Age began with
conquest of Istanbul by Turks which means in the same time
the fall of Byzantine Empire. In the New Age, there was a
progression in many areas, especially in Europe. Increase
in popularity of the press in Europe, Renaissance and Reform
movements are some of the important progressions in the New
Age.
The invention
of the press by Gutenberg (1448) is very important for
its increase of accessibility of knowledge. The press
which had been used in China beforehand was improved
after being known in Europe and many books started to
being pressed. The knowledge became more cheap, widespread
and accessible. |
|
Conquest of Istanbul
by Turks changed the balances of the world and caused the
beginning of the New Age. By the fall of Byzantine Empire,
the scholars in Istanbul escaped to Italy together with antique
manuscripts and played an important role in appearance of
Renaissance. Destruction of the city walls by cannons during
the conquest of Istanbul proved that feudalism could be destroyed.
Power and wealth of Ottoman Empire made the Europeans search
for new resources and effected the beginning of the Geographical
Discoveries.
Renaissance, “rebirth”,
began in Italy. From now on, human is the centre of everything.
Wishes, feelings and thoughts of human are important. The
thought wave that we call humanism appeared by examination
of antique sources. The church lost its authority by human
improving the thought. This movement also made progress in
all kind of art. Painting, music, sculpture and all other
art branches were effected by human gaining priority.
Renaissance was followed
by Reform movement. After Martin Luther had declared his thoughts
in Germany, Catholics and church’s authority were effected
badly. Calvin also started a movement similar to Luther’s,
in France. Reform had for purpose to return to essence of
Christianity, to purify the Bible from interpretations of
the church and people and to remove the church between human
and the God. Protestantism, which was founded with Reform,
gathered many followers especially in Germany and caused the
beginning of the Sect Wars. Despite the declarations which
gave equality to Protestants, like Nantes Decree, the Thirty
Years’ War couldn’t be prevented. The Thirty Years’
War lasting between the years 1618-1648 was an European war
which had been started because of the quarrel between Catholics
and Protestants. Many people died because of the war, the
epidemic started with war and the famine. The war passing
mostly in Germany left a ruined country behind. A radiant
period began in France. These wars which had also included
Spain and Sweden were ended with Treaty of Westphalia. Protestants
gained the freedom to believe and France widened its lands.
There were many massacres because of the different sects and
people suffered for many years. On the other hand, Niccolo
Machiavelli (1469-1527) who was one of the humanists of Renaissance
and who examined people’s passions and weaknesses, explained
how to utilize them for ruling people. And also, according
to the main idea of Machiavelli, “All the ways that
lead to the purpose are legal and ethic.” . Machiavelli
who is the first representative of the idea of nation-state,
is also considered as one of the innovators of the fascism
because of his thoughts which were used by fascists. It could
be called as foundation of fascism in the New Age.
If we consider the New
Age at the point of view of democracy, we can see many improvements
of thought. Human gaining priority, church losing authority,
art and science becoming freer are very important for democracy.
Despite the sect wars like the Thirty Years’ War, the
protestants gained their freedom to believe. In spite of the
fact that the totalitarian systems were founded; the New Age
was a very important process for freedoms. For a conclusion,
the scholastic thought of the Middle Age had been replaced
by freedom of thought at the New Age.
Ece Hepsen
Bibliography:
Büyük Larousse cilt 16 (baský:1986): Rönesans
Reform
Axis cilt 8 (baský:1999):Martin Luther Matbaa
Larousse L’histoire Universelle cilt 1 (baský:1960):Les
Temps Modernes
Büyük Larousse cilt 13 (baský:1986): Makyavelcilik
The French
Revolution and Democracy
|
The French Revolution
has enlightened and led the humanity during the 18th
century while the monarchy had all the power in Europe.
Although the success
was difficult and caused many deaths, the most important
aspect of the French Revolution which affected other
nations had been the consciousness of humanity. As the
people were conscious, they fought for equality, freedom
and being qualified to speak in politics i.e nations’
sovereignty all of which were inborn rights of the human
beings. During those days there were many similar attemps
but all were inconclusive in Europe where France was
the most populated country. Bad life conditions, injustices,
the war in America which was named “independence”
and declaration of constitution in England have incited
the French people to revolution.
|
|
The reason of American
independence war was the reluctance of 13 British colonies
in America in paying tax to Great Britain. In the end, this
small skirmish was named “Independence War” and
got a more important position. The declaration of American
independence (1776) which was declared at the end of the war
is very important from the view of democracy and human rights.
According to this declaration all human beings had the inborn
rights of living, freedom and being happy. All of the states
had been established to provide these rights, therefore all
of the administrators get the power with the consents of those
who are directed. “If a government behave in the opposite
of these targets, the nation can change this government with
a new one.” This declaration which has stressed the
importance of democracy has both affected the French people
and played a great role in the development of concept of democracy.
Of course the French
Revolution did not occur suddenly. In addition to visible
reasons, a lot of pioneer people had also contributed to the
development of the thoughts which constituted the bases of
the revolution. The famous French writer J.J Rousseau is the
most distinguished one of these people. How Voltaire has formed
the knowledge and intelligence of the French Revolution, in
the same way J.J.Rousseau has formed the emotionel world of
the revolution. According to J.J.Rousseau: all human beings
are free from birth but they have been chained everywhere
so the revolution is the legal way to get these rights back
and only the nations had the right of getting these rigths
back. Edgar Quinet said for J.J.Rousseau that whatever the
seeds mean for the trees, J.J.Rousseau means the same thing
for the revolution.
The regimen peaks in
the 1789 with all of these efforts and get the targets. On
the way to democracy king Louis the 16th wandered in the city
by carrying the flag with blue, white and red colors. Later,
the declaration for human beings and citizens was accepted.
(26 August) In the end, the republic as a democratic way of
administration was announced on the 21st of September.
Despite short life span,
the French Revolution is one of the most outstanding events
in the history of humanity which led to the closing of an
old age and opening a new one. The French Revolution which
had a great role in the formation and development of the concept
of democracy is an historical event that should be a good
example and lesson for the next generations.
Cisem Altundemir
Bibliography:
Ana Britannica
Théma Larousse
www.home.nordnet.fr
www.revolution.1789.free.fr
The
Major Reasons Preparing the
Tsar’s Russia to Bolshevik Revolution
and Democracy
The research of equity
and fairness of Russian people, lack of justice and freedom
led by the opressive and despotic admistration of Tsar; when
we researched the reasons and the bases of socio-economic
and socio-cultural structure of the reign of Tsar which was
occured mainly in the second half of the 19 th century and
the beginning of the 20 th century we consider the contradictions
in every field occured in the Russian Revelotion 1917 September.
On the way of democracy
of the strict and dictatorship of Tsar’s regime during
the reign of Petro I, and Alexander I, we witness both the
promotion of technical and professional traning and the increase
of the number of people trained widespreadly adn in 1803 the
emanicipation of the slaves who were brought and sold with
the land that they belong to.
During the reign of Tsar;
as its impossible to consider democracy in capitalism, a different
period was being led in Russia, which had incredibly different
social gabs between social groups, whose peasants felt opressive
and despotic pressure on them and where the nobles and the
owner of the private properties led luxury whereas a life
in labors died of hunger.
The peasants and labors
on behalf of constructing higher life standarts and the sake
of justice and freedom had to become concious affected by
the revolutionary and socialist thoughts and ideas at the
same term.
Even though the secret sociaeties were organized under leadership
of progressive officers and tried to take over the government,
this abortive insurrection of the Decemberists traumatized
Alexander’s succesor his brother Nicholas I, into a
policy of a reaction and repression. 5 Intellectuals were
hanged, hundereds of them banished. Therefore the ones who
based democracy and soverignty as their targets couldnt have
succeeded against Tsar’s persecution.
For the sake of the right
and freedom; the labors and peasants who couldnt express what
they wanted and what they thought if they did they were punished
curely through the way on democracy. (getting rid of slaver)
they emanicipated indivudially in 1861. They worked in factories
under terrible conditions and were paid low wages just to
act just like the developing European countries. Deciding
the importance of redistrubution of land (just to lead a normal
life) peasants wanted to establish a union with the factory
workers. This large social group which was supported by the
union with the help of the socialist thoughts, swept into
the political propagandas and revolutions in 1879.
At home in the 1860 s
radical university students and nihilist critics such as Nikolai
Chernyshevsky voiced dissatisfaction with the pace direction
of the reforms. Radical associations were formed to propagandize
socialist ideas, and student youth “ went to the people”
in 1874-76 to enlighten and revolutionize the peasantry. Repressed
by the government, the young radicals turned to terrorizm.
Eventually a group of Narodniki (populists) called the people’s
will condemned the Emperor to death, and after several dramatic
but unsuccesful attempt they killed him on March 13 1881.
As a result of natural
and social system of inequality with pressure and torture
caused the persecuters rebelled. However the rebellian prvoked
the opressive and despotic regime which means the owners of
the anti-democratic system made the solders and the politicians
on the democratic side stop supporting them. This position
helped the increse of the number of the subscribed the union
and rebellion enlarged.
To defect attention from the worsening social situation and
to neutralize the revitalized revolutinary movement, especially
among the workers, the government embarked on imperialist
adventures in the far East, provoking a war with Japan 1904-5.
The war triggered widespread diturbances within Russia including
the rural violance, labor unrest in St. Petersburg troops
fired on a large crowd of demonstrating workers. Bloody Sunday
, January 22 1905.
The turmoil of the Russian
revelotion of 1905, culminated in the general strike of October,
which forced Nikolas II to grant a constution.
In the event Russia went to war in August 1914. Determined
to prevent, The Russian government rallied to the support
of Serbia went Austria-Hungary declared war on the Balkan
Nation. Russia’s alliance with France and Britain and
Austria-Hungary’s with Germany helped transform the
local Balkan conflict into the WW I. The strains of the bloody
and the disastrous conflict produced a breakdown of both political
system and the social fabric in Russia. Food rights in Petrograd
and other cities troppled in Monarchy in March 1917.
After the collapse of
the temporary government, radical Soviet (Council ) of Soldiers’
and Workers’ Deputies was founded. In the following
years after the 1905 Revolution, Russian Social Democratic
Labor Party’s Menshevik Wing was defending to wait for
the capitalism to develop at the same time of the Bolsheviks
which were leaded by Lenin were unioned in a deciplined nucleus
and were predicting the proletary to take over the control
of the industry, Bolshevik’s believed that it was necessary
to have the democratic revolution and right after the Social
Revolution. In 1917, there were rebellions, people trying
to stay alive, fighting for their rights, proletaries trying
tp get their freedom. At this time Lenin was trying to emphesize
Marx’s theory to Russia and try to narrow down the road
of the temporary government. Bolsheviks were against the war
and the peasants which were the majority of the population
were trying to move the Soviet propagation to rural areas.
The Petrograd Soviet
found more reputation and authority than the temporary government
because in Russia there was a big mojar proletary community
which was supporting the Russian government. The government
was changed four times four times in between March and October.
The more the society bended to left, the more thegovernments
formed by coalitions. But these never stopped the war. It
never found a a solutions for the main country porblems. Soviet
whihc fitted in to the Petrograd model had the control.
In July the temporary
govenrment stopped a big coup but could not stop the retaining
in social, economic and military ways in Russia. Its trying
to hold still to the center caused its left wing to tear apart
and union with the other left revolutioners. Bolsheviks and
Left Socialist Revolutioners with the help of the Kerenski’s
warm Socialist Revoutioners, foremd the majority agains the
Mencheviks both in Petrograd and Moscow Soviet. “Peace,
Soil and Bread”, platform of Bolsheviks were attracting
the hungary workers of the cities and the ansents without
leave.
Eventually agrarain unrest, mass desertion of the non-Russian
nationalities gave the Bolsheviks under Vladimir Ilich Lenin
an opening to seize power in November 1917. Thus the second
of the two Russian Revolutions of 1917 occured.
Big Russian Proletary,
which was lack of equality and fairness, and also was pressured
under the opressive and despotic administration of the Tsar;
won their with their democratic revolution and socialist development
at the end of the 19th century. As a consequence with taking
a step on the way to the democracy, the Soviet Society gained
its rights from birth and became one of the most important
political, economic and military powers of the world.
Gülener Kýnalý
The
Mussolini government in Italy and the union of workers of
Marx
After the United
Soviet Socialist Republics, one of the new regimes that
the First World War brought within itself was the fascism
in Italy. The chaos in the domestic affairs in Italy
played the main role on the spreading of the fascism,
just like the example of the Bolchevics, who took control
of the government in Russia, by the help of the disorder
in the country and the dissatisfaction of the citizens.
The fascism which was applied by ‘Mussolini’
in Italy before the Second World War, and which was
known as ‘Nazism’ in Germany while the government
of Hitler was in charge, is based on inequality, anti-liberalism,
elitism and idealism, but not on materialism nor on
emotions. |
|
The consequence for Italy
who participated to the First World War with grand hope was
a grand desperation. By the time the war ended, the domestic
affairs of Italy were already complicated. The war had been
a massive effect on the economy. In addition to the liberal
democracy of Italy, the ideas of syndicalism, socialism and
communism could be observed. 50000 deserters who were hiding
themselves in every region of the country, morally and economically
dissatisfied discharged soldiers and intellectual citizens
were also causing a lot of trouble. The governments hadn’t
got the enough amount of authority for being able to govern
a country. The chaotic situation of the country had been useful
for the Fascist Party, which was directed by Benito Mussolini.
This political party, which was the enemy of communism and
liberalism, which was fore the discipline and nationalism,
has become the government of Italy in the month of August
1922. The citizens of Italy clung into the disciplinised soul
of fascism, in the anarchic situation of the country. That
event was the beginning of the Mussolini and the Fascist Party’s
dictatorship.
The first mission of
Mussolini was to individualize the government by abolishing
the opposition parties and the democratic establishments according
to the argument, which says ‘The regime that we constructed
is perfect, so there is no need for an opposition party.’
That was a reaction of the Europe after the war against the
liberalism of the nineteenth century. The confusion, anarchy
and instability of the large quantities of people had strengthened
the fashion of the regimes that are based on discipline.
Germany was another country
where the fascism increased its’ influence. Germany,
which was the resource of Nazism, was another country that
was dishonored by the loss of the First World War. Despite
being an industrially developed country, the Germany wasn’t
as powerful as England and France was in international marketing
and having raw material. The monopolies were dominant in industry
and public. The banks and industrial monopolies were working
together. Monopolizing was hardening to balance the economical
forces, so the construction of democracy. In 1929, the World
Economic Crisis affected the whole world, and the unemployment
level had increased. Nazis, by the help of these problems,
came to power and became the government of Germany. They defended
the Priority and the Privileges of the German Nation; they
talked about the rights of the ex-colonies and the harms of
the parliamentary system. According to their ideas, the system
of education should have been based on respecting the government,
and the middle classes should have been strengthened. They
promised to start a land reform, and to take steps against
the capitalist system, which looks for earning money without
any production. But when the Nazis came to power and became
the government, they never took any steps against the benefits
of the capitalist system.
The fascist regime who is fore the idea that equality and
liberty is inappropriate with the will of God, and that the
freedom of a person who isn’t aware of his profits is
harmful for the society, is totally against the democracy.
Sometimes, Mussolini and Hitler needed an approval for themselves,
and they made the citizens vote. But both of them took the
control and approval from the God. Hitler didn’t control
the government by the approval of citizens, he was accepted
because he was a Fuehrer, and he naturally came to power.
That’s why his strength was indefinite and uncontrollable.
Liberalism was not an ethical ideology, and the parliamentary
regime was the regime of ‘irresponsibility and weakness’.
Hitler used to repeat this expression a lot: ‘A president
who spends his time with trying to persuade the members of
a parliament cannot operate.’
 |
On the other
hand, when you look at the Union of Workers of Marx,
you can see the democracy. In a speech that he has prepared
for the workers, he spoke about how the workers were
miserable, and about how these people couldn’t
buy even nitrogen and carbon necessary for curing the
illnesses who were the consequences of hunger. He declares
the reality that three thousand people were sharing
the annual earnings of the agricultural workers of England,
he refuses that and offers the workers to unite. Marx,
who is on the workers’ side, and who defends the
democracy is totally the contrary of Hitler and Mussolini. |
Sevil Altinoz
Bibliography:
www.haberbilgi.com
www.st_cyprus.co.uk
|